A Case of Conscience (Del Rey Impact) [James Blish] on *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. Winner of the Hugo Award • The future of Earth will . A Hugo-winner from near the end of Blish’s most creatively fertile decade, A Case of Conscience does not, in this humble reader’s opinion, stand up to the test of. One distraught reader responded to A Case of Conscience by sending author James Blish a copy of the Vatican’s teachings on extraterrestrials.

Author: Vibei Kigul
Country: Zambia
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Science
Published (Last): 13 March 2016
Pages: 332
PDF File Size: 15.2 Mb
ePub File Size: 6.77 Mb
ISBN: 114-3-47472-125-9
Downloads: 70439
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Tokree

Much the same meaning “situation” mutated to “condition” applies when one speaks of a “medical case” and, although the term is not used in relation to the poisoned Cleaver, that is what he is. Their world is a utopia of reason with no war and only minor conflict.

The first half of the book is more interesting in sci-fi terms, with the world building and if of an alien culture. Egtverchi, on the run, is on the way to Lithia having smuggled himself “aboard the vessel that was glish the final installment of equipment to Cleaver” and, as it happens, carrying a pilot model of the circumcontinuum radio whereby the captain communicates the discovery of Egtverchi to the count.

In doing so he enters into what he believes to be a Manichaean heresy of believing that the Adversary has creative powers. Certainly there is nothing very saintly about Egtverchi’s equivalent of Christ’s 12 disciples, the “ten nearly identical young men in uniforms of black and lizard green with silver piping, their arms casd, their expressions stern, their eyes straight ahead” First, this is dated.

A Case of Conscience – Wikipedia

Certainly, og repeated references to Ruiz-Sanchez’s interest in the meaning of a particularly complicated passage in Finnegans Wake require some kind of explanation. Stake out plots; grow crops; abandon the corridors. Oct 20, Tony rated it really liked it Shelves: Chaos ensues, blah blah blah.

But it is unfortunate that some early classics feel poorly constructed, and that reflects the tenuous state of the genre jmaes in the Golden Age of Astounding and Galaxy before full-length SF really hit its stride. Topics Fiction Books blog. To purchase, click on image. Jun 29, Tony rated it it was ok. Retrieved from ” https: Follow Ted Gioia on Twitter at www.


God v Satan in deep space

Apparently Cleaver had not been communicating with them and so Michelis and Agronski had decided to travel to Xoredeshch Sfath and find out what has been going on.

There are two broad approaches: He quickly learns about the world, and starts to question why humans are living in underground shelters brought about by earlier nuclear conflict. When the team is reassembled, they compare their observations of the Lithians.

What do I get, instead?

The opposition which Bradham posits here between life and a sterile academicism simply does not apply. Lithia, presumably, was to be the lithium planet. Blish’s second thoughts, if that is what they were, appear in a letter to Pohl dated 6 March Blish, Reilly argues, explores the limitations of three types of knowledge: For Ruiz-Sanchez, in fact, as for Cleaver, Lithia is a wolf in sheep’s clothing, a utopian surface disguising an amazingly destructive potential.

The planet seems just too good to be true. In this reading, we are not supposed to sympathize with Ruiz’s heartfelt struggle with science and doctrine, but we are supposed to mock it.

My reading of the novel was that he knew very little on the topic. Sanchez’s spiritual tussles and troubling “night thoughts” are moving and there’s real fun to be had in engaging with Blish’s imaginative descriptions blisy strange Lithian technology and weird stinging plants. A great thank you to James Blish and Open Road for the opportunity to read this book and offer an unbiased review.

The attentive reader cannot be so certain.

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. One doesn’t have to be personally religious to speculate about being a religious person, of course, but he would have to acquire an expertise in some other manner.

A Case of Conscience (After Such Knowledge, #4) by James Blish

Retrieved January 9, All I could think was: There is only one solution: Once the book breaks away from the hollow character of Arestide it focuses on Egtverchi, who enters in a way I can’t really jamees because it made no sense.

Many of the “insects of Lithia” make “wing-case buzzes” like the “insects of Earth” 1: Since we follow connscience humans through many pages of their own internal maunderings, I found the book ultimately pretty boring. The climactic end of the book seems to point that way, but Blish did leave a wiggle room for an alternate secular explanation. InFather Ramon Ruiz-Sanchez of PeruClerk Regular of the Society of Jesusis a member of a four-man acse of scientists sent to the planet Lithia to determine if it can be opened to human contact.


He had lost his place in the church and was doomed to self-destruction without it – just as a third of society had become disconnected with the UN presumably because of a lack of access to nature?

As will appear when I resume my summary of the action, this does come to pass. The White Hotel Tiptree, Jr. Jul 14, Jeff F rated it did not like it Shelves: In A Case of Conscience we get a speculative fiction puzzle: That party in the many-levelled underground mansion developed from what was once a trolley-car storage center is clearly intended as an analogue of Dante’s Hell spiced with elements which might derive from The Satyricon.

The new houses assumed thousands of fantastic, quasi-biological shapes, not quite amorphous fase not quite resembling any form in experience, either; they looked a little like the dream constructions once made by an Earth painter named Dali out of such materials as boiled beans.

Michelis, conzcience chemist, and Agronski, a geologist. Jo Allen Bradham, in what is to date the consciehce detailed explication of these matters, elucidates the religious implications of the setting of the Message Tree. The comscience then thickens and the way is paved for the book’s bizarre second half when Chtexa hands Ruis-Sanchez his aa, Egtverchi, packed in a flask in embryo form and the commission head back to earth where the alien child wreaks havoc.

D avid Ketterer Covering A Case of Conscience Alien beings, as SF writers present them, come in every variety of shape, substance, size, and color but, from at least one Christian’s point of view, there can only be three essentially different types.